basically i want all your opinions on 4 players, in any league, that are currently off form, on form, overrated and underrated

mine are:

Off form - Fernando Torres - Poor performance against Man U today
On Form - Dimitar Berbatov - Hattrick today!

Overrated - David Villa - Dont rate at all...
Underrated - Bacary Sagna - He's a quality Right Back

villa overrated cmon m8 you had a few beers today have we .

Yea I agree with red Villa is quality

He's not the player for me he doesn't even score for me on football manager!

Off form: Rooney or Torres
On form: Mackie (QPR) Berbatov

Overrated: Ibrahimovic
Underatter: Darren Fletcher (amazing today against liverpool)

Agree with them Jon

Off Form.. Hart

On Form.. Tevez

Overrated.. Berbatov (even with his goals)

Underrated.. Pavluchenko

Wasn't the equaliser his fault?

Off Form: Torres + Carragher (shouldnt be startin ahead o agger)
On Form: kalou + Nani

Overrated: A. Cole(still very good) + A. Johnson (still good but not the world beater the madia make him out to be)
Underrated: Kalou + Corluka

I think for your overrated that A.Johnson should be changed to G.Johnson, cos it's exactly the same description lol

glen johnson gets slated about his defendin so wouldnt say hes overrated

Yeah but he is at first put out as a world wide star... when actually... well he's crap.

lol whatever mate he aint as good as some ppl make out ..When you says hes crap and you dont rate villa beginning to question your judgment on players

torres earned peno and free kick which he scored from did he not?

off form: Torres, Hart
on form: Milner, Malouda

overrated: Torres and Villa
underrated: Andy Carroll as he is on fire at the mo but people don't recognise him as decent

he did not score gerrard did

Stevie G scored both

off form: Torres, Gerrard
on form: Milner, Malouda

overrated: Gerrard,Drogba

underrated: Villa,Xavi,Fabergas

drogba is ace and is not overrated

off form carragher
on form bale

overrated : lennon
underrated : carroll