Players just need to decide who they want to be with before the season starts.
A lot of the time players are perfectly happy until other captains start working on them to move this rule stops all those arguments.
This is my 3rd season and the first 2 had constant arguing between clans about poaching now we still find other things to argue about but it's normally over in a flash whereas those just dragged on and on.

when you say one might be allowed ,,, what happens if 2, 3 or 4 ask to leave which one is allowed to go ????

the suggestion in my oppinion is asking for more trouble

What about our case I described earlier?
There was no fight between the captains, she hadn't even played a game for them as far as I know. Yet she has to sit out the entire season (12 weeks = 3 months). Surely that's not what this league is about? We want members playing and enjoying themselves not being disqualified without ever playing.

Give them a quarantine similar to deactivating (1 month) and people won't move much. Only those that would stop playing for the other clan anyway (because of falling out etc) will take the suspension just to move.

I did say if they havent played a game they would still be allowed to move seb.
Bit like being cup-tied in football, why should the same team have to face the same player with 2 different teams...3 times in a season?

i had with yetti in fbl

i asked about it and was told no transfer because he had been signed only played pre_qual

what im saying is if the captain wont release then the player should go to the league and they will make the call

the runners asking for both sides to be put forward then make a discision

its obvious in a case like tht the league would say free to become a free agent and the league would then tell the clan captain

It wasn't a case of a fight. The player was released, yet still not allowed to play due to transfer rules.

Even if they've played 1 set. Have to wait another 10 weeks (plus the break between seasons) to play again? Not good. Doesn't help anyone.

Good point

seb there are 2 sides to that one

if the player say caused a load of problems you know what i mean im sure then he shouldnt be allowed

a one thats genuine should become a free agent and allowed to play

my oppinion

what is the point in keeping a player if he dose not want to play for you i think one transfer for one player is good if he leave that team as well he can not play in another team again all season

Like some of the suggestions that have been brought up here, one of them i actually was talking about already .

The votes have now passed the 25 mark and will probably be more by the morning, there will be another announcement made tomorrow remembering clans about the vote then the poll will shut a few hours after. Unsure on the time as of yet.

Craig you are right to there will be a tweak to what ever one is picked in the poll. Thanks for the nice comments to.

It is wrong and a one fixture wait should be more than enough rather than a month.

Just to say, we have been working on the new season schedule for next season. It is slightly changed but i think this will be more liked, just making sure we have not missed anything out or anything like that. It will be posted when it is ready. and will also be followed nothing will be changed unless we feel it needs to be.

yetti hmmmmmmmmm youve changed your tune

if a player is committed to the team and has played games then if he dosnt want to play then release him thats his choice and yours as a captain,,,,,,,,,, your example means if the player dosnt want to play anymore why transfer him why not let him sit out the rest of the season ,,,,,,,,,, dont get this one sorry

Edited at 08:37 Mon 02/01/12 (GMT)

yetti was told by you that we was folded that was the only reason why he left us
and for you to get one over on me so it you going to be honest tell the truth about it

that all am going to say on it
and if others don't believe me i keep it all i just copy and paste to them

Edited at 10:42 Mon 02/01/12 (GMT)

mid season transfer, 1 week if you want to move thats ur time, very simple, very fair what else can i say anything else wud be a mistake, keep it as simple as possible.

mmmmm youve changed your tune
when 2 of your players did not want to play for your team but you just give them so much headache trying to keep them no point keeping them just let them go if they unhappy with the team

yeah i agree with u mouse , he kept me and harry there all last season when we both wanted to leave . if a player is unhappy he should be allowed to leave . its a game at the end of the day .

this why i said it should be one transfer per person
if a player is not happy in the clan this way he got the right to move on
everyone stated it meant to be fun where the fun in that if a player is not happy in a clan
the captain should not have no right to kept a player if he not happy once he dose one transfer he or she can not move to a another team

this way kept s all the members happy if they want to join a clan
no clan should have a foot hoe on players its wrong as it for fun

I think if a clan gives a player a chance they should have more respect for the clan and captain than jumping ship mid-season because they don't like a decision or because they are playing well and a bigger team wants them.

it down to captain to make sure the players are happy with in the clan team
if a player is loyal to you then they will not move anywhere
so i think if their not happy their should be giving the chance to move on in good reason